Today’s Marketing is a Bar
Friday, April 13th, 2007"You talk about social media, you yak about ‘new marketing ecologies,’ and I still don’t get it," a lot of our clients say. "Why can’t I just keep doing the usual, buying media, placing ads, doing some research now and then?"
And that’s a completely fair question. There’s so much change going on around us that it’s hard to keep up with it all. People forget that, only 10 years ago, they didn’t really have to worry about email, web marketing, online advertising, keywords, or online video–let alone social media and virtual worlds. They might not have even had a website yet.
So how do you describe this new environment that brands are working in?
Simple. It’s a bar.
But wait. Before we get to that, let’s go back to school. Literally. Because that’s what the old marketing environment looked like. Literally.
Yes, I’m serious. Consider this:
Past Marketing: You’re in School
You stand in front of a roomful of people. You tell them what you want to tell them, using visual aids when you need to. Sometimes the people in the room talk to each other. Sometimes they don’t pay attentionMost of the time you aren’t really thrilled with that. Over the course of a day, the people in the room see many other people standing in front of them, telling them how it is. But, again, there’s not a lot of talking. Not a lot of discussion.
- Your brand is the teacher, standing in front of the room
- The students in the room are your audience
- You have a significant share of voice
- You have a good deal of their attention
- They have to sit in front of you for a reasonable amount of time, even if they don’t really want to
In this scenario, if you present your ideas well and you’re easy to get along with, you’re going to be well-liked, and people are going to remember you at the end of the day.
Today’s Marketing: You’re in a Bar
Now, you’re still standing in front of a roomful of people. But the rules have changed. You’re standing behind the bar, and people are crowding around. The people aren’t there because they have to be; they’re there because you’re delivering something they like. Or they may not like what you’re serving, but their friends are there. Or they just happened to be in the neighborhood. Some of them are nice, some of them aren’t so nice. And they can talk to each other.
Seeing how this is different? Consider this metaphor:
- Your company is the bartender, standing in front of a crowded bar
- The people in the room may or may not be your audience
- You have almost no share of voice
- You probably don’t have their attention, beyond how you are immediately serving them
- Nobody has to hang out with you
In fact:
- They can talk right back to you
- If they don’t like what you’re serving, they can go somewhere else
- They can talk to each other, and decide what they think about you
- If they decide you’re a loser, you’re a loser
- Some of them will be jerks, period
- And it all happens in real time, immediately
Social media means that every communication is a conversation, that it happens immediately, and that there are real penalties if you ignore it. It also means your share of voice is, effectively, gone. With over 50% of all online content generated by your customers, you can’t out-shout the crowd. And, even then, nobody likes a bully.
So yes, you could continue your broadcast advertising plan, put off deploying social media on your site, and hide behind yearly research–but every moment you run your bar like a school increases the chance your patrons will find another, more friendly, abode.